Thanksgiving 2026 Pie Sale and Ice Cream from Cold Comfort!

from $10.00

Thanksgiving 2026 Pre-Sale

We are back this Thanksgiving with with lots of old favorites and a couple of “new” classics:

Cherry Pie with Rye & Cocoa Nib Streusel $45

A Beara classic. Tart Michigan cherries with a rye, and cocoa nib streusel, caraway, poppy seeds and rolled oats.


Chocolate Oatmeal Cream Pie $45

An oatmeal cookie crust with chocolate mousse filling and toasted meringue

Burnt Honey Pumpkin Pie $45

A classic pumpkin pie with a swirl of burnt honey

Peanut Butter and Concord Grape Jam Pie $45

A creamy and light peanut butter mousse with a layer of our most coveted (and labor intensive) Concord grape jam, and a house-made graham cracker crust.

Take-and-Bake Cheddar Chive Biscuits (4 ea) $18

a sure way to impress your friends and family this year


**But wait! There is MORE!
**

We are teaming up with Cold Comfort this year because what goes better with pie than ice cream?

The selection: Pumpkin Ice Cream with Fall Spice, Dark Chocolate, Vanilla Malt, Mint Chocolate Chip, Spiced Pecan, Brown Butter Sage, Coffee, and Strawberry Buttermilk

Pick up Wednesday November 25th, 2pm-6pm at 10 N Washington St (Ypsilanti) OR 3pm-5pm at Argus Farm Stop Cafe on Packard (Ann Arbor)

PLEASE MAKE SURE TO DOUBLE CHECK YOUR SELECTED PICK UP LOCATION BEFORE ORDERING. Thank you.

Offerings:

Thanksgiving 2026 Pre-Sale

We are back this Thanksgiving with with lots of old favorites and a couple of “new” classics:

Cherry Pie with Rye & Cocoa Nib Streusel $45

A Beara classic. Tart Michigan cherries with a rye, and cocoa nib streusel, caraway, poppy seeds and rolled oats.


Chocolate Oatmeal Cream Pie $45

An oatmeal cookie crust with chocolate mousse filling and toasted meringue

Burnt Honey Pumpkin Pie $45

A classic pumpkin pie with a swirl of burnt honey

Peanut Butter and Concord Grape Jam Pie $45

A creamy and light peanut butter mousse with a layer of our most coveted (and labor intensive) Concord grape jam, and a house-made graham cracker crust.

Take-and-Bake Cheddar Chive Biscuits (4 ea) $18

a sure way to impress your friends and family this year


**But wait! There is MORE!
**

We are teaming up with Cold Comfort this year because what goes better with pie than ice cream?

The selection: Pumpkin Ice Cream with Fall Spice, Dark Chocolate, Vanilla Malt, Mint Chocolate Chip, Spiced Pecan, Brown Butter Sage, Coffee, and Strawberry Buttermilk

Pick up Wednesday November 25th, 2pm-6pm at 10 N Washington St (Ypsilanti) OR 3pm-5pm at Argus Farm Stop Cafe on Packard (Ann Arbor)

PLEASE MAKE SURE TO DOUBLE CHECK YOUR SELECTED PICK UP LOCATION BEFORE ORDERING. Thank you.